Best Ice Cream & Dessert in Ocean City

I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream! The beloved dessert everyone loves to enjoy in the summertime.

We can see it now: you’ve just spent a long day at the beach and are looking for the perfect way to wind down and end your evening. The kids are in the back of the car, and they really were pretty good all day…they deserve a treat! When you’re looking for a place to grab a sweet treat, we know there can be endless options.

While it can be said that no ice cream is bad ice cream, It’s a special occasion, so you want to make an informed decision on where to go. Don’t worry; we like to consider ourselves experts in the ice cream arena. We’ve gathered a list of the best ice cream in Ocean City, Maryland so that you can’t go wrong!

Dumser’s Dairy Land

Take it from a local; this is the best ice cream shop around. Dumser’s first ice cream batch was made in 1939, and they’ve been making people happy with their cones ever since. Enjoy a variety of homemade ice cream, milkshakes, sundaes, floats, and more at this iconic stop.

Dumser’s originated in a small shop selling homemade ice cream on the boardwalk and has since expanded to seven locations in Ocean City. Even though the business has grown, they still prioritize quality over quantity and pride themselves on their homemade creations. We could go on all day about how much we love Dumser's, but you’ll have to try it yourself to get the full experience!

By the Bay Creamery

Another great option! This ice cream place has a wide selection of flavors, many of which we’d guess you’ve never heard of before (Have you ever had an ice cream flavor named Kitty Kitty Bang Bang? They carry it! It's cheesecake flavored ice cream with raspberry swirls mixed in...so good!).

Try a free sample of their many unique flavors to find out your favorite before you make your choice. They even have a bourbon-spiked espresso flavor called the "Exhausted Parent"—does that ring any bells? Regardless of the flavor you pick, By the Bay's reviews are always consistently stellar. Customers can't stop coming back for more!

Sweet Frog

Mmm, did someone say frozen yogurt? Sweet Frog is the place to go for this delectable delight! If you’ve never been to a Sweet Frog before, you’re in for a treat.

Choose from one of several fro-yo flavors (local favorites include Island Banana and Cotton Candy), and then select a variety of toppings to add excitement and flavor to your dessert! With all the toppings available, things can get pretty crazy, so keep an eye on your kids—before you know it, they could have a cup filled to the brim with candy toppings.

You can make fairly healthy choices here, too. The entire experience is make-your-own, so you can combine your frozen yogurt with fruit or deck it out with all the sugary candy you can muster. It's your call!

King Kone

Get a taste of delicious Hershey’s ice cream right here in Ocean City! King Kone has been serving up impressive cones since 1996.

King Kone’s ice cream is second only to its welcoming atmosphere and friendly customer service. Locally owned and operated, owners Rick and Shelly have made it their mission to provide not only high-quality ice cream, but top-notch customer service.

Whether you're in the mood for a classic cone, a sundae, or a milkshake, King Kone has you covered. On your trip to Ocean City, be sure to stop by King Kone for great ice cream and friendly service. Plus, you can take a photo with their gorilla statue to add to your vacation scrapbook.

Dodo Cookie Dough & Ice Cream

Sometimes, you’re just craving some cookie dough. What if you could try a delicious ice cream/cookie dough combination? You CAN—at Dodo’s!

Dodo’s specializes in creating the ultimate dessert: a mix of ice cream and edible cookie dough. Their menu is ever-changing, with a wide selection of fresh edible cookie dough, ice cream flavors, and sweet toppings to satisfy everyone’s sweet tooth and personal cravings.

You can try a scoop of cookie dough or ice cream or get multiple scoops to enjoy both together. Their signature Sundaes include dishes like “Dodo Tracks” (Chocolate ice cream, nuts, marshmallows, hot fudge) and Peanut Butter Lovers (Chocolate/vanilla ice cream, Reese’s Pieces, peanut butter cups, peanut butter sauce). All in all, Dodo’s serves up delectable delights and a can’t-miss experience!

Annabelle’s BBQ & Creamery

Authentic southern barbecue and delicious ice cream, all in one place? Sign us up!

Annabelle’s serves up barbecue with authentic Southern hospitality, flavor, and charm. They believe passion is the most important ingredient in the kitchen, and their food is packed full of it!

Once you’ve had some famous BBQ, you have to try their homemade ice cream. You can even try a boozy milkshake if you want to let loose a little bit! Their ice cream is creamy and delicious—you won’t leave Annabelle’s disappointed.  

Book Your Vacation to Ocean City with Century 21 New Horizon!

Planning a trip to Ocean City? Your choice of accommodation is the cherry on top! At Century 21 New Horizon, we want to be sure you have the best vacation experience possible. Whether you’re looking for access to indoor pools, tennis courts, or fitness facilities, our rentals provide a range of impressive amenities.

Check out our specials and browse all available vacation rentals today to book your next trip to Ocean City direct with Century 21 New Horizon!